Servus,
Zitat
greetings after my 12h dayshift.
I`m amused and become a little bit angry.
Wow!!! Please don`t!
Zitat
You red the briefing and our last mails?
I tried to explain it step by step, I failed.
Of course I red. You succeeded, do not rush to be upset. Just part of our agreements with you, I duplicated here.
Zitat
>>>My russian friend and me, we are not from RA, we are from steelbeasts.ru (steelbeasts.pro).
sorry for this, I will change this in the final version.
My dear friend, you can call me as you wish, even may be "Natasha", but the main point of this to make it clear that I have come to ask you to play a serious games.
Zitat
>>>So we can not understand why this mission have 1985 date, and the red on the offensive? Why all the current funny missions contain the offensive of the red?
I want to play red as offensive part, because in my opinion it was there doctrine.
>>>We had a defensive military doctrine.
lol
What the "lol"?
At 1989 all studying programs in Soviet Army was about defensive military doctrine only for desinformate German officers from DDR? It`s realy lol.
I will check for 1985. May be it was time of quick changes and you would be right.
Zitat
>>>>The main problem of the mission, it's difficult weather conditions and very limited visibility. In such circumstances, we can not go on the offensive and prefer to wait for the right weather conditions, even against your company we would have an entire division. We do not need the losses.
>>>>>Besides. We do not understand what is the "capture of an object", we understand the "reaching of the frontier", and why we need to capture the Kalinka in this terrain, if above it rises the height of the most dominant to the west?
>>>>>From a tactical point of view, we would have preferred to attack in the souther direction, or in the worst case, in the norther direction of this area. In general, we would prefer to choose offensive conditions ourselves, because it is our offensive. But much work has been done, and we offer a compromise.
>>>>>It is necessary to exclude from the height of the game, marked in purple or revise the target of the attack.
I can make sunshine and visibility 3000m, no problem good for our Leopards. I don`t wanted to write a novel in the situation reports.
The situation is like I described in the mission. Red found a gap in our defense and sent this MechInf Btn to take this key terrain and to develop the situation.
If you use google maps, you can see our Brigade is defending between Detmold and Paderborn. So if you can take your OBJ you have 2 options for future operations (we will not play these options).
1st you can go west or you can attack the deep left flank of our Btn or Brigade.
Back to the situation.
The blue Btn Cdr saw this gap and sent one PzGrenCoy to defend the area. Thats why it`s a hasty defense for blue.
It is not your offensive. You play a MechInfBN and you follow orders from your RGT CDR or DIV CDR. In good old red army doctrine a MechInf CDR has not the option, he follows orders, strictly.
If you like you can download the regulations in our download section.
Alles anzeigen
Welldone!!! Glad to read this.
But when we read the briefings, it seemed to us that you have not seen the map, and you simply whant a fire range. If you know our doctrine then why you propose to take an "object"? But mostly impotant: Why do you propose to take the town located in the bowl? The commander of our regiment (division) idiot?
I wrote all thise bulky duplicate texts to set up all for a serious game. But if we are discussing an important task for the division, and playing for the battalion at the same time can't properly put a local task and making so extremal weather under the beautiful legend, then the point is lost.
Zitat
To the south is the main effort of your division and our brigade because there are the main roads. I was not scripting this and I will not make a script.
Of course it is not necessary to script more. But if we can not agree on mutual concessions, the need broader understanding of the situation and the further we are away from the playing of initial mission of SB.
All we need is necessary to shorten the map from the west to the object Kalinka.
Zitat
You can use the missiles from your BMPs,
Of coure we cant in this visibility.
Zitat
our Marder can`t do this (in real life yes, but not in sb), we have to dismount squads. The only thing we have is the terrain. We have to find out your main effort and have to defend very flexible.
Do not complain about the SBMarders, they destroy SBT-72 tanks, but the SBtanks have time to sweat before destroy the Marder, and SBBMP-2 can`t to damage them even the stern. But we do not discuss this.
Zitat
We can speak about the time limit, but we need this in my eyes.
Yes.
Previously in such circumstances, we should be able to go through the "whole" map by foot, 80 minutes is not enough. The shorter the map, the faster play. In any case, timing is not ready yet.
Zitat
What we can do, we can play it and after this we change sides and see what happens.
We don`t like this idea.
Regards,
LAN